Gappy`s Pizza in Carmel

Gappy`s Pizza in Carmel
4 / 5
50 reviews

1323 Route 52, Carmel, NY 10512-4557, Carmel

Overview

Cuisine
  • Italian
  • Pizza
Features
  • Takeout
  • Seating
  • Waitstaff
  • Serves Alcohol
  • Reservations
  • Wheelchair Accessible
Good for
  • Families witd children
  • Kids

Restaurant Hours

Monday

11:00 am

Wednesday

11:00 am

Friday

11:00 am

Sunday

11:00 am

Why won’t your business answer my call at 11:00 on a Saturday but get?

Wait a little ..Worth it....Best Italian food and 🍕 this side of Saturn.

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Gappy`s Pizza
RS
Robert Stark
google
11.23.2024
5/5

The food here is very good. I especially love their pizza and their chicken fingers. I have eaten here for years and the staff is always very friendly and attentive. The one thing I will point out is that this place is always packed around dinner time so there may be a lack of parking sometimes but don't let that discourage you from eating here. It is definitely worth the wait.

Gappy`s Pizza
JN
Jennifer Nanek
google
08.18.2018
5/5

Love the pizza here..but they have good soup and salad too. Service is friendly and there is a casual atmosphere.

Gappy`s Pizza
MT
Michael Torres
google
08.11.2018
5/5

I went there with some friends and my GF, the service here is great! They give you complimentary warm bread and butter and the bread is perfectly crunchy and soft on the inside.We had ordered garlic knots, these were very good. They were of course warm, but they were very soft as well, very good. They served them with a great sauce! We had also ordered mozzarella sticks, these were fantastic. The cheese was very soft, and the breading was flavorful.Our group shared a large pizza. Definitely the main event. We had gotten a red pizza with cheese, sweet sausage, pepperoni, garlic, spinach, and half with pepperoncini; excellent. The pizza was not greasy and the cheese was incredible, it stretched for ages lol!

Gappy`s Pizza
EM
Elizabeth Medina
google
06.27.2018
5/5

Food was delicious will be back soon

Gappy`s Pizza
FN
Felix Nazario
google
06.26.2018
5/5

Great service and pizza!

Gappy`s Pizza
UA
UwU Account
google
06.14.2018
5/5

Always satisfied!! Never a complaint. Their food is an A+

Gappy`s Pizza
Am
Anthony m Petrillo
google
06.12.2018
5/5

Love this place! Best pizza no doubt .great food fair prices....😊

Gappy`s Pizza
st
stephanie tsourlakis
google
06.05.2018
1/5

Went inside to order a few items. Specifically ordered to hero’s. Before I could ask myself the girl at the front asked if I wanted the bread toasted.. yes please.: Come home to find the chicken was barely cooked.:: the bread was not toasted and now soggy..Gross.. no problem taking my money tho.:

Gappy`s Pizza
SB
Sage Boi
google
06.03.2018
5/5

Fantastic food besides its amazing pizza. Just a great overall family restaurant. Just be warned, parking is a bit tight.

Gappy`s Pizza
RL
Ryan Lyke
google
06.02.2018
4/5

Good food, reasonable price. Would be a five, but crowded weekend nights are very loud inside and you are packed in tightly

Gappy`s Pizza
GB
Gina Burchfield
google
05.21.2018
5/5

Great tasting and they never disappoint!!

Gappy`s Pizza
AS
Andrea Servedio
google
05.16.2018
3/5

Great service and the place was packed for a Friday. The food was decent.

Gappy`s Pizza
RC
Rachel Clark
google
04.03.2018
5/5

Expensive but our favorite in the area

Gappy`s Pizza
RA
Robert A. RAS
google
03.19.2018
5/5

First time today ever at Gappy's ordered a single slice and calamari frame diavolo over linguini. both were excellent, the slice was thin and had a crisp crust with great taste. The calamari was cooked just right, linguini was aldente and the sauce was excellent, you would not know you were having a restaurant sauce, it was that good. Thank you for a great meal.

Gappy`s Pizza
af
arthur ford
google
03.07.2018
5/5

Great food staff is amazing..

Gappy`s Pizza
MB
Mike B
google
03.01.2018
5/5

Always great food at great prices.

Gappy`s Pizza
AD
Alexandra Dinucci
google
11.01.2017
5/5

Fast service and great food

Gappy`s Pizza
MG
Morgan Gallagher
google
10.18.2017
1/5

I agree with Nonya, they have multiple unsanitary employees, these employees have multiple posts on their social media’s with attachments of them promoting not wearing a mask in public & not washing hands. As a customer, I do not feel comfortable ordering food and eating it from a place where a workers are not being safe. You have lost my business.

Gappy`s Pizza
TC
Tom Castello
google
10.18.2017
5/5

Consistent good food with friendly service

Gappy`s Pizza
MA
Mike A
google
10.18.2017
5/5

Great food at reasonable prices...

Gappy`s Pizza
CR
Charlotte Riopel
google
10.16.2017
5/5

Pizza's are HUGE! Excellent, too!! Wonderful menu!! Huge, fresh salads! Waiter was on top of everything. It was easy off and easy on the highway. If you're on I-84 near the CT border and you love pizza... You have to stop here!!

Gappy`s Pizza
JF
Joey Fox
google
10.12.2017
4/5

Stop here for a slice every once in a while. Slices are huge, inexpensive and tasty. Worth a stop in to try.

Gappy`s Pizza
rG
rbrts916 Gums
google
10.10.2017
1/5

Pizza is good but I got a calzone and it was cold and raw. We unfortunately didn't notice until we got home from our pick up. We tried to put it in our oven and cook it, 45 minutes later it's still raw....It's just disappointing. Raw dough like that is gross and feels lazy for a pizzeria.

Gappy`s Pizza
RR
R RCL
google
09.24.2017
5/5

Top notch Service friendly staff excellent food .

Gappy`s Pizza
jt
john taylor
google
09.18.2017
5/5

Awesome folks good food

Gappy`s Pizza
AB
Annie B.
google
07.25.2017
5/5

Good food, friendly staff, quick and close to home. My favorite pizza place.

Gappy`s Pizza
rh
r howard
google
07.09.2017
5/5

Always good pizza, love this place

Gappy`s Pizza
JM
Jasper Mastico
google
07.01.2017
5/5

Really good pizza and just off the highway. Great for a quick stop. Highly recommend the mozzarella sticks

Gappy`s Pizza
JK
John Kleine
google
07.01.2017
4/5

Great food and service. Love the big pizza slices. Big negative is the cheap, flimsy containers they use for takeout. What a mess they leave! Make sure they double up the trays on your order or you’ll be cleaning up a mess like I just did

Gappy`s Pizza
MH
Mark Haimson
google
06.16.2017
5/5

Awesome portions, everything is always fresh n delicious. Ask for Jean for the BEST service in town!

Gappy`s Pizza
AK
Aron Kelly
google
06.15.2017
5/5

I really enjoyed the dishes and customer service, good location close to my residence. The staff members are always friendly. Highly recommended.

Gappy`s Pizza
RM
Richard Muscarella
google
06.13.2017
5/5

Very good food, great portions well worth the moneyfriendly staff

Gappy`s Pizza
PW
Peter Warren
google
06.13.2017
5/5

Gappy's is the best. Great pizza, pasta, generous salads, nice beer selection and everyone there is very friendly.

Gappy`s Pizza
BS
Bradford Schalkham
google
06.11.2017
5/5

Great NY pizza. Generous portions, tasty salads and quality service.

Gappy`s Pizza
JC
Johnny Conyers
google
05.19.2017
4/5

Very nice mix crowd. Courteous attentive Waiters

Gappy`s Pizza
RD
Rachelle Doring
google
04.06.2017
5/5

Great food & service! They know their regulars by name!

Gappy`s Pizza
AK
Alexander Kontoleon
google
02.09.2017
5/5

If you want pizza and basic Italian fare done right and delicious then you come here. No fancy decor, food is great. It's a local favorite for a reason.

Gappy`s Pizza
CW
Christian Wessel
google
11.25.2016
5/5

Great food, friendly staff, always has quick service if I want to pick up something on the way home.

Gappy`s Pizza
SH
Steven Hoffman
google
11.06.2016
4/5

Good pizza pretty fast service

Gappy`s Pizza
JS
Jerry Stein
google
09.22.2016
4/5

Food is consistently good. A little noisy at times but nothing very disturbing.

Gappy`s Pizza
DG
Diana Guerrero
google
09.16.2016
5/5

Fast friendly service, pizza was delicious

Gappy`s Pizza
TM
Tammy Mousa
google
09.05.2016
5/5

Best Pizza in town! Staff is wonderful, friendly and extremely welcoming. The Food is Excellent!!! From the Burgers to the pasta dishes.

Gappy`s Pizza
ST
Steven Tomassetti
google
08.13.2016
5/5

Great food. The staff are excellent there. One of the go to pizza places in the area

Gappy`s Pizza
TS
Tripp Scott
google
06.26.2016
5/5

The meals and service were above my expectations. I surely enjoyed the vibes of this restaurant. Superb spot to take my family out for lunch.

Gappy`s Pizza
RS
Renee Sabatini
google
06.12.2016
4/5

Good food good service great price!

Gappy`s Pizza
GG
Gary Gladstone
google
06.03.2016
2/5

Short on ingredients and flavor. Tasted like a midwestern pie. Not satisfying. Something missing so I went back to try another extra sweet sausage, still not much flavor so the third time I ordered extra cheese and extra sausage. Didn’t work. Got home and- figured that the problem was that there was little or no tomato taste from the sauce. I’m now too scared to try it s third time,

Gappy`s Pizza
TK
Tom Kelley
google
05.23.2016
5/5

Outstanding pizza and food. Had the chicken parm tonight. Loved it.

Gappy`s Pizza
LG
Lee Giella
google
04.21.2016
1/5

They used to be very goodthen something changed. Service not so good. Food not as good as it was. I figured any restaurant can have a bad day so i gave them one more chance and still sub std. So i found another place and it's much better.

Gappy`s Pizza
CR
Collin Radier
google
04.16.2016
4/5

Great service and huge slices

Gappy`s Pizza
NB
Nonya Besniss
google
04.09.2016
1/5

Don't know how to feel. Like the pizza but very unfortunate they have an unsanitary employee, Jackie Zerbo. Have posts attached of her promoting not wearing a mask in public, not washing hands, and being in public as often as she'd like. As a customer, I do not feel comfortable ordering food and eating it from a place where a worker is not being safe. Also encouraging nurses to not wear masks, very unprofessional. If the safety of others is not a concern to you, you should stay home. Thanks!

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 18458780800

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!